Eva Noblezada (Hadestown, Miss Saigon) will return to the role of Daisy Buchanan, joined by Reeve Carney (Hadestown, Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark) as Jay Gatsby, as the production celebrates its second anniversary on Broadway.

Noblezada returns to the musical on Thursday, February 5, 2026, where she will reunite with her original co-star and current Jay Gatsby, two-time Tony Award Nominee Jeremy Jordan (Floyd Collins, Newsies), for several weeks prior to his final bow on Saturday, March 7, 2026. The current Daisy, Broadway standout Aisha Jackson (The Notebook, Once Upon a One More Time), will play her final performance as Daisy Buchanan on Sunday, February 1, 2026.

Reeve Carney will take his first bow as Jay Gatsby on Monday, March 30, 2026, playing opposite Eva Noblezada as Daisy.

Ryan McCartan (Heathers, Disney’s Liv and Maddie) will return as Jay Gatsby from March 8 – March 29, guest starring between Jordan’s and Carney’s runs, and will also step into the title role during Jordan’s previously scheduled personal days February 5 – 9.

Continuing in the cast are Broadway favorites Michael Maliakel (Aladdin) as Nick, Linedy Genao (Bad Cinderella, On Your Feet!) as Myrtle Wilson, Austin Colby (Frozen Tour) as Tom Buchanan, Samantha Pauly (Six) as Jordan Baker, Charlie Pollock (Urinetown, “The Good Wife”) as George Wilson, and Eric Anderson (Waitress, Kinky Boots) as Meyer Wolfsheim. The production’s standout ensemble features Alexis Hasbrouck (Moulin Rouge Nat’l Tour), Curtis Holland (Mean Girls), Nathaniel Hunt (Moulin Rouge Nat’l Tour),  Traci Elaine Lee (Shucked), Dariana Mullen (The Great Gatsby at Paper Mill), Mariah Reives (Funny Girl), Elena Ricardo (Water for Elephants), Dan Rosales (Trevor: The Musical), Dave Schoonover (Bad Cinderella), Mike Schwitter (Pippin), Tess Soltau (Once Upon A One More Time), Preston Taylor (Moulin Rouge Nat’l Tour), Jessica Mallare White (Aladdin Nat’l Tour), Matt Wiercinski (Anastasia), Kyla Stone (Harmony). Kurt Csolak (Funny Girl), Haley Fish (Cats), Morgan Harrison (Beetlejuice), Justin Keats (Moulin Rouge Nat’l Tour), Drew Lake (The Great Gatsby in Korea), Brandon J. Large (Aladdin Nat’l Tour), Alicia Lundgren (Funny Girl), and Alex Prakken (New York, New York) round out the cast as swings.